Hello and welcome to the Discourse. Poetics by Aristotle is a foundational work of literary criticism that examines the principles of poetry, particularly tragedy and epic poetry.
While the original text is not explicitly divided into chapters, modern editions often break it down into sections for easier analysis. Researchers believe that the work was composed around 330 BCE and was preserved primarily through Aristotle's students' notes.
While the original text is not explicitly divided into chapters, modern editions often break it down into 26 sections or chapters for easier analysis.
Summary of Poetics:
In Chapter 1, Aristotle introduces and defines poetry as a form of imitation (mimesis). It can imitate noble actions, people, or events. A poet has three means of imitation at his disposal——rhythm, language, and harmony. He may employ metres too, but the distinguishing merit of a poet is not that he writes in metre, but that it is an imitative nature of his work. He distinguishes between different types of poetry: epic, tragedy, comedy, dithyrambic poetry, and music. He says poetry differs based on the medium, objects, and manner of imitation.
In Chapter 2, Aristotle discusses the Objects of Imitation. He says that Poetry imitates human actions, which can be noble or base. Characters in poetry are either better than, worse than, or similar to real-life people. Tragedy imitates noble actions, while comedy imitates base or ridiculous actions. In Chapter 3, Aristotle discusses the Manner of Imitation. Poetry can imitate through narration, direct action, or a combination of both. Epic poetry uses narration, while drama (tragedy and comedy) uses direct action. The poet may imitate by narration -in which case he can either speak through another personality (which is purely narrative), or he may present all his characters as living and moving before us. This latter type is called drama.
In Chapter 4, he discusses Origins and Development of Poetry. He offers instinctive and psychological origins of poetry and says that Poetry arises from human instincts for imitation and rhythm. He also discusses historical origins of various forms of poetry. Tragedy evolved from improvisations by leaders of dithyrambs (choral hymns), while comedy originated from phallic songs. Tragedy developed over time, with Aeschylus and Sophocles contributing to its structure.
In Chapter 5, Aristotle explores and defines Comedy and Epic Poetry. He says that comedy is an imitation of men “worse than the average” which is not the same thing as bad characters. Comedy imitates inferior characters and focuses on the ridiculous rather than the harmful. He defines Epic Poetry and says that Epic poetry shares similarities with tragedy but differs in length, structure, and meter (epic uses hexameter). Tragedy is more concentrated and unified than epic poetry.
In Chapter 6, he offers Definition and Elements of Tragedy. Tragedy is defined as the imitation of a serious, complete action that evokes pity and fear (catharsis). The six elements of tragedy, in order of importance, are Plot (mythos) – the arrangement of events, Character (ethos) – the moral qualities of the agents, Thought (dianoia) – the reasoning behind characters' actions, Diction (lexis) – the choice of words, Melody (melos) – the musical elements, and Spectacle (opsis) – the visual elements. Aristotle stresses that the Plot is the main element of a tragedy and says, “A tragedy is impossible without action, but there may be one without character.”
In Chapter 7, he discusses the Structure of the Plot. According to his definition, a tragedy is an imitation of a whole action. A good plot must have a beginning, middle, and end. It should be complete, with a logical sequence of events. The plot should be of a reasonable length to allow for a change of fortune.
In Chapter 8, Aristotle stresses the Unity of Action. The plot must have unity of action, meaning all events should be connected and necessary to the story. Episodic plots, where events are not causally linked, are inferior.
In Chapter 9, he discusses Universality and Probability in poetry. Poetry deals with universal truths, while history deals with specific events. He suggests that poetry is better than History. The plot should follow probability or necessity, meaning events should happen logically.
In Chapter 10, Aristotle discusses Simple and Complex Plots. Plots are either simple or complex. A plot is simple when there is neither any unexpected change or reversal of situation nor a sudden discovery. A complex plot includes both Discovery and Reversal. A simple plot has a single, continuous action without a reversal or recognition. A complex plot includes a reversal (peripeteia) and/or recognition (anagnorisis), which are more effective in evoking pity and fear.
In Chapter 11, he further elaborates on Complex Plots and discusses Reversal, Recognition, and Suffering.
Reversal (Peripeteia) refers to a sudden change in the protagonist's fortune, often from good to bad, that is crucial to the plot.
In Oedipus Rex by Sophocles, Oedipus begins the play as a respected king of Thebes, determined to save his city from a plague. However, his investigation into the murder of the former king, Laius, leads to the shocking revelation that he himself is the murderer and that he has unknowingly married his mother, Jocasta. This reversal transforms him from a noble ruler into a tragic figure doomed to exile and suffering.
Recognition (Anagnorisis) is the moment when a character moves from ignorance to knowledge, often revealing a critical truth about their identity or situation.
In Oedipus Rex, the moment of recognition occurs when Oedipus realizes that he is the son of Laius and Jocasta, the king and queen he unknowingly killed and married. This revelation shatters his sense of identity and leads to his tragic downfall.
Suffering (Pathos) refers to a destructive or painful action, such as death, agony, or loss, that evokes pity and fear in the audience. After discovering the truth about his identity, Oedipus blinds himself in a fit of despair and is exiled from Thebes. His physical and emotional suffering is a direct result of his actions and ignorance.
In Chapter 12, Aristotle discusses the Parts of Tragedy. He divides tragedy into quantitative parts: prologue, episode, exode, and choral sections.
In Chapter 13, he describes The Ideal Tragic Hero. The tragic hero should be a person of high standing who is neither wholly good nor wholly evil. The hero's downfall results from a tragic flaw (hamartia) or error in judgment. Aristotle says that the best tragedies evoke pity and fear through the suffering of a relatable hero. In Oedipus Rex, Oedipus's tragic flaw is his hubris (excessive pride) and ignorance. He believes he can outwit fate and avoid the prophecy that he will kill his father and marry his mother. His determination to uncover the truth, while admirable, blinds him to the possibility that he himself might be the cause of Thebes's suffering. Shakespeare’s Hamlet suffers the tragic flaw of Indecisiveness and overthinking. Macbeth’s tragic flaw is Ambition and susceptibility to manipulation.
In Chapter 14, Aristotle elaborates on Pity and Fear. Pity is evoked for someone who does not deserve their suffering. Fear is evoked when the suffering could happen to anyone. The best plots involve suffering within families, such as murder or betrayal among kin.
In Chapter 15, he discusses Character in Tragedies and says that Characters should be good, appropriate, consistent, and true to life. They should also be consistent in their actions and speech.
In Chapter 16, he describes Types of Recognition (Anagnorisis). Aristotle describes various forms of recognition, such as recognition by signs, through memory, or through reasoning. The best recognition arises naturally from the plot.
In Chapter 17, Aristotle offers some Practical Advice for Poets. Poets should visualize the action as they write. They should outline the plot before adding details and characters. Poetry implies either a happy gift of nature or a strain of madness. Aristotle reminds the poets that the Chorus should be regarded as one of the actors and should not be used for providing mere interludes.
In Chapter 18, he discusses the Complications and Resolutions of a Tragic Plot. The complication (desis) is the part of the plot where the conflict develops. The resolution (lysis) is the part where the conflict is resolved. The resolution should arise naturally from the plot, not through external means like divine intervention (deus ex machina).
In Chapter 19, Aristotle discusses Thought and Diction of a Tragedy. Thought refers to the themes and ideas expressed by the characters. Diction refers to the choice of words and style of language.
In Chapters 20-22, Aristotle discusses Language and Grammar to be used in poetry. He discusses the parts of speech, metaphors, and the importance of clarity in diction and emphasizes the use of appropriate and effective language. Diction should be clear but not mean.
In Chapters 23-24, he elaborates on Epic Poetry. Epic poetry shares many elements with tragedy but is longer and more expansive. It should also have unity of action and focus on a single theme. The plot in epic poetry should be constructed on dramatic principles. There should be a single subject, whole and complete. It should resemble a living animal in all its unity, differing in construction from history, which presents not a single action but a single period. The difference between Epic poetry and Tragedy lies in the scale and the meter, on which they are constructed. In Epic poetry, hexameter is used.
In Chapter 25, Aristotle addresses common Criticism of Poetry and explains how to evaluate a work. He emphasizes that poetry should be judged based on its own rules and goals, not external standards. He elucidates that the meaning of poetic truth as distinguished from the truth of fact. Aristotle emphasizes that the poet presents not facts but his own view of facts. A probable impossibility should be preferred to improbable possibility.
Chapter 26 offers a comparison between Tragedy and Epic Poetry. Tragedy is superior to epic poetry because it is more concentrated, uses more artistic elements (like spectacle and music), and achieves its effect more effectively. Possesses all the epic elements, it may even use the metre used in epic and has the additional advantage in its use of music and spectacle. Moreover, the canvas of tragedy being shorter, it has more concentrated effect; whereas, the bigger canvas and diffusion through a long extent of time, weaken the impression in Epic.
Critical Analysis:
In Poetics, Aristotle focuses almost exclusively on tragedy, giving limited attention to other forms of poetry, such as comedy or lyric poetry. His analysis of comedy, for example, is largely lost, leaving a gap in his theoretical framework. His definition of tragedy as requiring a noble protagonist, a unified plot, and a cathartic effect is seen as overly prescriptive. Many great works of literature, including modern tragedies, do not conform to these rules. Aristotle prioritizes plot (mythos) over character (ethos), arguing that character is secondary to action. This has been criticized for undervaluing the role of complex character development in storytelling. His insistence on the unity of action (a single, coherent plot) has been criticized as limiting. Many great works, such as Shakespeare’s dramas, episodic novels or postmodern narratives, thrive on multiple plotlines and fragmented structures. Aristotle emphasizes that events in a plot must follow probability or necessity. This has been criticized for excluding the role of chance, randomness, or the absurd in literature.
Aristotle wrote the work as a counterargument against Plato’s opposition to poetry and other art forms. According to Plato, poetry is "thrice removed from reality" because it imitates an imitation of the Forms (the ultimate reality), making it a distant and imperfect representation of true knowledge and reality. While Plato criticized mimesis (imitation or arts) as deceptive and inferior, twice removed from reality, Aristotle suggests that man can only imitate, and mimesis is natural, educational, and capable of revealing truth. However, Aristotle maintains that all poetry is imitation (mimesis). This view has been criticized for reducing literature to mere representation, ignoring its creative, expressive, and transformative potential.
So this is it for today. We will continue to discuss Classical Literary criticism. Please stay connected with the Discourse. Thanks and Regards!
No comments:
Post a Comment