Hello and welcome to the Discourse. Sense and Sensibility is Jane Austen's first published novel, marking her debut as a professional writer. Originally drafted in the late 1790s under the title Elinor and Marianne, it was significantly revised before being published anonymously in 1811 by Thomas Egerton. The novel was attributed only to "A Lady," a common practice for female authors at the time to avoid societal prejudice. Subsequent works would similarly avoid her name, instead being attributed to "the author of Sense and Sensibility" or another of her novels. Though Austen received modest financial compensation, the novel's success laid the groundwork for her subsequent literary career. A second edition was released in 1813, further cementing its place in English literature.
The novel explores themes of rationality versus emotion, social class, gender constraints, and the economic vulnerability of women in Regency England. Austen contrasts the personalities of the two Dashwood sisters—Elinor representing "sense" (prudence and restraint) and Marianne embodying "sensibility" (emotional intensity and romantic idealism). Through their experiences, Austen critiques the societal expectations placed on women, particularly in matters of love, marriage, and financial security. The novel also satirizes hypocrisy and vanity within the upper classes, a recurring concern in Austen's works. It is widely believed that Sense and Sensibility was deeply influenced by Jane Austen’s own relationship with her sister, Cassandra. The bond between Elinor and Marianne Dashwood mirrors the dynamic between the Austen sisters—Elinor’s steady, rational nature reflecting Cassandra’s role as the composed and practical older sister, while Marianne’s passionate impulsivity aligns with Jane’s own spirited and emotional tendencies. This personal connection lends the novel an intimate quality, offering readers a glimpse into Austen’s own life and affections. The novel’s exploration of sisterly love, loyalty, and contrasting temperaments resonates on a deeply personal level, as it seems to preserve the essence of Austen’s closest relationship.
While Sense and Sensibility holds historical significance as Austen’s debut, modern critics often regard it as one of her less polished works. Some argue that Elinor and Marianne embody extreme traits—reason and emotion—without the depth of her later heroines, while male leads like Edward Ferrars and Colonel Brandon are frequently criticized as uncharismatic. The novel’s conclusion has also faced scrutiny for abrupt developments, such as Marianne’s sudden acceptance of Colonel Brandon and Lucy Steele’s unexpected elopement with Robert Ferrars. Compared to Austen’s later masterpieces, the social satire is less incisive, and the plotting occasionally uneven. Nevertheless, the novel remains a vital milestone in her career, offering insight into her early development as a writer and foreshadowing the wit and keen observation that would define her legacy.
Character of Sense and Sensibility:
The Dashwood Family
The novel centers on the Dashwoods, a family left in precarious circumstances after the death of Henry Dashwood, whose estate, Norland Park, passes entirely to his son John due to England’s inheritance laws. John, though initially well-intentioned, is easily swayed by his selfish wife, Fanny, and neglects his promise to provide for his stepmother, Mrs. Dashwood, and his half-sisters. Mrs. Dashwood is a woman of warmth and sensibility but lacks prudence, often acting on impulse. Her eldest daughter, Elinor, embodies "sense"—she is rational, composed, and self-disciplined, concealing her own heartache to protect others. Marianne, the middle sister, represents "sensibility"—she is passionate, expressive, and deeply romantic, openly pursuing love without restraint. Margaret, the youngest, is spirited but less developed in the narrative, serving mostly as an observer of her sisters’ contrasting natures.
The Ferrars Family and Connections
Edward Ferrars, the elder son of the wealthy and controlling Mrs. Ferrars, is a kind but indecisive man trapped between familial duty and personal happiness. Though honorable and gentle, his passivity complicates his relationship with Elinor, whom he admires, and Lucy Steele, to whom he is secretly engaged. His brother, Robert Ferrars, is a vain and foolish dandy who inherits his mother’s favor after Edward’s defiance. Mrs. Ferrars herself is a domineering figure who values status over happiness, disowning Edward when he refuses to marry for money.
The Middletons and Their Social Circle
Sir John Middleton, a distant cousin of Mrs. Dashwood, offers the family refuge at Barton Cottage. He is hospitable and good-natured but lacks depth, filling his home with constant guests. His wife, Lady Middleton, is elegant but cold, more concerned with propriety than genuine connection. Her mother, Mrs. Jennings, is a well-meaning but meddlesome gossip who delights in matchmaking. Colonel Brandon, a close friend of Sir John, is a reserved and honorable man with a tragic past; his quiet devotion to Marianne contrasts sharply with Willoughby’s flashy charm. John Willoughby, a dashing and charismatic suitor, sweeps Marianne off her feet but proves morally unreliable, having abandoned Colonel Brandon’s ward, Eliza Williams, in a previous scandal.
Secondary Characters and Antagonists
Lucy Steele, a cunning and socially ambitious woman, manipulates Edward’s sense of honor to maintain their secret engagement. Her sister, Anne Steele, is foolish and indiscreet, inadvertently exposing their schemes. The Palmers—cheerful, oblivious Charlotte and her sardonic, disinterested husband—provide comic relief while reflecting the triviality of some societal marriages. Finally, Miss Sophia Grey, the wealthy heiress whom Willoughby marries for financial security, serves as a foil to Marianne, highlighting the harsh realities of love versus materialism in Regency England.
Through these characters, Austen explores themes of love, morality, and social expectation, using wit and irony to critique the flaws and virtues of each.
Summary of Sense and Sensibility:
The story is divided into three volumes. Volume I opens with the death of Henry Dashwood, whose estate, Norland Park in Sussex, passes entirely to his son John from his first marriage due to England's inheritance laws. Henry's second wife, Mrs. Dashwood, and their three daughters - Elinor (19), Marianne (16), and Margaret (13) - are left with only £500 a year between them. Though Henry made his son promise to care for his stepmother and half-sisters, John's selfish wife Fanny soon persuades him to give them only minimal assistance.
Fanny's brother, Edward Ferrars, comes to stay at Norland and forms an attachment with the sensible Elinor. However, Fanny disapproves of the potential match due to the Dashwoods' reduced circumstances. Mrs. Dashwood, offended by Fanny's behavior, accepts an offer from her cousin Sir John Middleton to rent a cottage on his Devonshire estate, Barton Park.
At Barton Cottage, the Dashwoods meet their new neighbors: the jovial Sir John, his cold wife Lady Middleton, and her mother, the well-meaning but gossipy Mrs. Jennings. Colonel Brandon, a quiet 35-year-old bachelor and friend of Sir John, is immediately drawn to Marianne's musical talent and spirited nature, though she considers him too old for romance.
During a walk in the hills, Marianne twists her ankle and is dramatically rescued by the dashing John Willoughby. Their shared love of poetry and music sparks an intense connection, and they spend every day together. Willoughby even gifts Marianne a horse (which Elinor prudently convinces her to refuse due to their limited means). The planned picnic with Colonel Brandon was canceled when urgent business called him away. Willoughby, now free to devote himself entirely to the Dashwoods, became a constant presence at their cottage, his attentions to Marianne growing increasingly open. He spoke warmly of his affection, leaving Mrs. Dashwood and Elinor certain that an engagement was imminent.
Hoping to encourage a proposal, Mrs. Dashwood, Elinor, and Margaret discreetly left Marianne and Willoughby alone one morning. But upon their return, they found Marianne in tears and Willoughby hastily preparing to leave for London. He offered no real explanation—only vague excuses—before departing abruptly. Marianne was inconsolable, while Elinor grew uneasy. Had they quarreled? Were his intentions ever sincere? Marianne refused to speak of it, leaving the family in anxious uncertainty. No letters followed, deepening Elinor’s suspicions. Mrs. Dashwood clung to hope, but Willoughby’s sudden coldness cast doubt on his earlier fervor. The once-promising romance now hung in unsettling silence.
Volume II
Mrs. Jennings invites Elinor and Marianne to London for the winter season. Marianne eagerly hopes to see Willoughby, while Elinor quietly longs for news of Edward. In London, Marianne writes repeatedly to Willoughby but receives no reply. At a party, they encounter Willoughby, who coldly greets Marianne and later sends a cruel letter denying any special affection and announcing his engagement to the wealthy Miss Grey.
Marianne falls into deep despair. Colonel Brandon reveals to Elinor that Willoughby had seduced and abandoned his young ward, Eliza (the daughter of his first love), leaving her pregnant and destitute. This scandal caused Willoughby to be disinherited by his aunt, forcing him to marry for money.
Elinor finds herself reluctantly drawn into Lucy Steele's confidence during their time in London. In a calculated move, Lucy steers their conversation toward the Ferrars family, prompting Elinor to inquire about their connection. With feigned reluctance, Lucy drops her bombshell: she and Edward Ferrars have been secretly engaged for four years, since Edward was studying under her uncle, Mr. Pratt. The revelation strikes Elinor like a physical blow. Though initially stung by Edward's deception - having led her to believe his affections were free - her keen perception quickly recognizes the true nature of his predicament. Lucy, with her vulgar manners and transparent manipulations, proves to be punishment enough for Edward's indecision. The jealous way Lucy monitors Edward's interactions with Elinor, coupled with her obvious social climbing ambitions, makes it painfully clear that Edward has bound himself to a woman who values status over genuine connection.
Rather than giving in to bitterness, Elinor pities Edward's plight. She maintains her composure, recognizing that any protest would only fuel Lucy's spiteful nature. In this moment, Elinor's "sense" prevails over wounded pride, as she silently acknowledges the cruel irony that Edward's honor has trapped him in a match that will bring neither party happiness. Though heartbroken, Elinor keeps this secret and maintains her composure.
Volume III
The Steele sisters' stay with John and Fanny Dashwood ends disastrously when Lucy's secret engagement to Edward is revealed. Mrs. Jennings brings news of the furious Ferrars family ejecting the Steeles from their home. Edward's furious mother disinherits him in favor of his foolish younger brother Robert. Marianne is shocked by both the engagement and Elinor's long silence about it. Edward, bound by honor to Lucy despite his changed feelings, faces disinheritance unless he can secure a living. Colonel Brandon unexpectedly offers him the Delaford parish, a generous gesture that pains Elinor as it facilitates Edward's unwanted marriage.
As spring arrives, the party travels to Cleveland, where Marianne's heartbreak manifests in a dangerous fever after reckless walks in the rain. While the Palmers flee with their child, Mrs. Jennings and Elinor nurse Marianne, joined by an anxious Colonel Brandon. When her condition worsens, Brandon heroically fetches Mrs. Dashwood. During the crisis, Willoughby makes a startling appearance, confessing to Elinor that financial pressures forced him to abandon Marianne for a wealthy marriage. Though still loving Marianne, he acknowledges his wrongdoing, earning Elinor's measured sympathy.
Marianne's recovery brings newfound maturity. She makes peace with Willoughby's betrayal and recognizes her past selfishness, particularly toward Elinor. When news arrives of Edward's supposed marriage to Lucy, Elinor's composure finally breaks, revealing her hidden feelings. The emotional climax comes with Edward's unexpected arrival - Lucy has actually married his brother Robert because he inherited the fortune of his family, freeing Edward honorably. His heartfelt proposal to Elinor is joyfully accepted.
The novel concludes with dual happy endings: Elinor and Edward marry and settle at Delaford with financial help from the grudging Mrs. Ferrars. After two years of growth, Marianne reciprocates Colonel Brandon's steadfast love, their marriage proving that sensibility tempered by experience can find lasting happiness. Mrs. Dashwood remains at Barton with Margaret, while the sisters maintain their close bond, their contrasting journeys demonstrating Austen's balanced view of sense and sensibility in navigating life's challenges.
So this is it for today. We will continue to discuss the history of English literature. Please stay connected with the Discourse. Thanks and Regards!
No comments:
Post a Comment